If you’re hunting for some of the very best pizza in Brooklyn, you’ve come to the right place. From Williamsburg to Coney Island, we’ve scoured the borough to bring you the 25 Best Pizza Places in Brooklyn for 2023.

Whether you’re a classic New York slice fan, a deep-dish enthusiast, or a lover of the thin and crispy, we’ve got something for you.

Each pizzeria on our list brings something unique to the table, from coal-fired crusts to wood-fired wonders and toppings that range from the traditional to the downright adventurous.

So, grab your appetite and sense of adventure, and join us as we embark on a journey through Brooklyn for the best pizza in Brooklyn.

divider

History of Pizza in New York and Brooklyn

Pizza made its grand debut in New York and Brooklyn at the dawn of the 20th century, brought over by Italian immigrants who missed the flavors of home. These early pizzas were cooked in massive coal-fired masonry ovens, originally built to bake bread.

The first pizzerias were simple, small-scale operations, often set up in the back of Italian grocery stores.

However, the delicious combination of dough, sauce, and cheese quickly won over New Yorkers’ hearts (and stomachs), and these humble pizzerias began to grow in number and popularity.

As the years passed, pizza evolved to reflect the unique spirit of New York. The thin, crispy crusts and generous toppings that we associate with New York-style pizza today are a far cry from the Neapolitan-style pies of the early days.

This evolution is a testament to the city’s ability to take something traditional and make it its own. Today, pizza is as much a part of New York’s identity as the Statue of Liberty or Times Square.

And now, let’s get to the good stuff-the pizza. Here are the 25 Spots for the Best Pizza in Brooklyn for 2023. Bon appétit!

25 Spots for the BesT Pizza in Brooklyn

1. Grimaldi’s – A Coal-Fired Pizza Love Story

Neighborhood: Dumbo
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect for: Family dinners, casual meet-ups with friends, or even a fun date night.

If you’re on a quest for the best pizza in Brooklyn, or heck, even the entire country, you’ve got to make a pit stop at Grimaldi’s. This place isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s a pizza institution serving up slices of heaven since 1990.

Patsy Grimaldi founded this spot, one of the city’s last pizza strongholds that still uses a coal oven. Yes, you heard that right, a coal oven. It’s like a time machine that takes your taste buds back to the good old days of pizza-making traditions that span over a century.

Now, let’s talk delicious pizza.

Grimaldi’s has a smorgasbord of specialty pies that will make your mouth water just by reading the menu. And if you’re feeling like a pizza Picasso, you can even build your own pizza masterpiece.

Some crowd favorites include the Margherita, Garden Pesto, and Prosciutto Arugula. But let me tell you, no matter what you choose, your taste buds are in for a treat.

Just a heads up, Grimaldi’s is a hot spot for both New Yorkers and tourists alike, so there’s usually a line waiting to be seated.

But don’t let that deter you.

The wait is just a prelude to the pizza symphony that awaits inside. And remember, they don’t do slices here, only whole pies. Because why have a slice when you can have the whole thing right?

And for all my gluten-free and vegan pizza lovers out there, don’t fret! Grimaldi’s has got you covered with a Gluten-Free pizza crust option and a vegan-friendly cheese-less Garden Pizza.

The Brooklyn Bridge pizza is a great choice from the menu; topped with ricotta cheese, red peppers and Italian sausage, its perfection on a plate.

Grimaldi’s is not just about pizza. They’re also hugely involved in donating to charity. They’re currently in partnership with No Kids Go Hungry and help thousands of kids yearly. So, when you’re enjoying a pizza at Grimaldi’s, you’re also helping a good cause.

2. Speedy Romeo – A Race for Flavor in Every Slice

Neighborhood: Clinton Hill
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies only
Perfect For: A Casual Night Out with Friends

Speedy Romeo is your next pizza destination if you’re a fan of wood-fired, St. Louis-style pizza and Italian-influenced dishes. Nestled in the heart of Bed-Stuy, this pizzeria opened its doors in January 2012 in a former auto parts shop.

Talk about a transformation.

The cooks at Speedy Romeo wear striped mechanics’ shirts with name patches sewn on, a nod to the pizzeria’s automotive past. But instead of fixing cars, they’re fixing up some of the best thin-crust pizzas in Brooklyn.

The pizzeria is named after one of the owners’ family’s champion racehorses, adding a dash of whimsy to your dining experience.

And let’s talk about their pizzas.

View of Truffle Shuffle pizza from Speedy Romeo's, one of top spots for the best pizza in Brooklyn.

The White Album is a cheese lover’s dream come true. With roasted garlic, ricotta, Provel, pecorino, and some kind of béchamel, it’s a white pizza that’s as rich in flavor as it is in history.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at cheese. The Dick Dale, with speck, pineapple, Provel, and grilled scallions, is a delightful combination that’s sure to have your taste buds dancing.

Speedy Romeo also offers an array of classic Italian dishes and sides to enjoy. And with online ordering, delivery, and take-out options, it’s easy to get your hands on this delicious pizza.

3. Valentine’s Pizza – (Sadly, they have since closed since writing this)

Neighborhood: Bed-Stuy
Pie vs. Slices: Offers both Pies and Slices
Perfect For: – A Low-Key Date or Family Dinner

Valentine’s Pizza is an old-fashioned pizza parlor in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn. Since they opened their doors in 2021, the team at Valentine’s has been serving up some of the best slices of ‘za in BK, all from a coal oven.

Whether you’re a traditionalist who loves a good Margherita or a vegan looking for a pie that doesn’t compromise on flavor, Valentine’s Pizza has got you covered. They even offer a vegan Margherita option that’s as tasty as it is animal-friendly.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at pizza.

Valentine’s Pizza also offers calzones that are as hearty as they are flavorful. And if you’re feeling adventurous, why not try their Vodka pizza? With basil, mozzarella, and a rich vodka sauce, it’s a flavor explosion that’s sure to delight.

At Valentine’s Pizza, you can have your pizza your way. They offer 18-inch pies for those who like to share (or just really love pizza) and slices for those who want a quick bite. Just be prepared to wait around 30 minutes when ordering a full pie – good things take time, after all.

So, if you’re ready for a pizza experience that’s as unique as it is delicious, then make your way to Valentine’s Pizza. Remember, at Valentine’s Pizza, every slice is a slice of love.

4. Cuts & Slices – Where Unique Toppings Meet Pizza Perfection

Neighborhood: Bed-Stuy
Pie vs. Slices: Slice
Perfect For – A quick grab-and-go meal

If you’re a fan of unique toppings and crave a Brooklyn pizza experience that’s a cut above the rest, then Cuts & Slices is your next pizza destination. This pizzeria, which first opened its doors in 2018, offers slices that are anything but ordinary.

What sets Cuts & Slices apart from the rest are their unique toppings, including chicken & waffle, black truffle alfredo shrimp, and lasagna. But the main attraction? Their oxtail pies. With three options, including sweet chili, these pies are a must-try for any pizza enthusiast.

Lines often snake out the door at Cuts & Slices, so it’s a good idea to get here early. But trust me; the wait is worth it. Their chewy crust will remind you of a buttermilk biscuit, adding a delightful twist to your pizza experience.

And the best part?

They have a lengthy menu that includes vegan, jerk chicken parm, and seafood selections. So, whether you’re a meat lover, a seafood enthusiast, or a vegan, they’ve got something for you.

The pizzeria has a couple of tables and a counter for standing, making it the perfect spot for a casual night out with friends.

5. Juliana’s – Where Pizza Traditions Meet Modern Tastes

Neighborhood: Brooklyn Heights
Pie vs. Slices: Pies
Perfect For – A Night Out with the Family

If you’re searching for a pizza experience that’s as rich in history as it is in flavor, then Juliana’s is the place to be. This pizzeria is the main Grimaldi alternative and is named after the original founder’s mother, Juliana.

Juliana heralds the return of Patsy Grimaldi, NYC’s most celebrated pizza proprietor, to 19 Old Fulton Street, the original location under the Brooklyn Bridge where he and his late wife, Carol, founded the legendary Grimaldi’s Pizzeria.

In 2012, they “unretired” to partner with their close friend to establish Juliana’s, proudly preparing and serving pies.

The pizza here is in the chewy, charred Neapolitan style, and they use a coal-burning oven, the same as their neighbor. They close each day beginning at 3:15 pm to stoke their coal oven and cannot bake or serve pizza during this time. They reopen to new guests promptly at 4 pm.

They do not offer reservations or group events, so getting there early is a good idea. But trust me; the wait is worth it. They also offer a handful of non-traditional pizzas topped with ingredients like salmon and goat cheese for those looking for a pizza adventure.

6. Il Colosseo – The Authentic Taste of Italy in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Bensonhurst
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: – Date Nights, Family Gatherings, and Pizza Enthusiasts

Il Colosseo, a beloved pizzeria in Brooklyn, is a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic Italian culinary experience. Since its establishment, it has been a favorite among locals and visitors alike, earning a reputation for its top-tier pizzas and warm, inviting atmosphere.

The pizzeria is renowned for its wood-burning brick oven pizzas, crafted with the utmost care and precision. The dough undergoes a long fermentation process, resulting in a deliciously crunchy crust that perfectly complements the fresh, high-quality toppings.

The menu is diverse, featuring various pizzas to cater to every palate. Each pie is a testament to the pizzeria’s commitment to quality and flavor, from the classic Margherita to the unique Special Del Colosseo Pizza.

One of the standout pizzas is the Pizza di Bufala, which features tomato sauce and imported bufala mozzarella. The Pizza Vodka, topped with mozzarella and homemade vodka sauce, is another crowd-pleaser.

For those with a penchant for seafood, the Pizza Frutti di Mare, adorned with clams, mussels, shrimp, and calamari, is a must-try.

Il Colosseo also offers a variety of other Italian dishes, including pasta, risotto, and meat dishes. The Pasta Pescatore, featuring squid, mussels, clams, and shrimp, is a seafood lover’s dream, while the Veal Pajarda offers a hearty option for meat enthusiasts.

7. Roberta’s – The Hipster Haven of Brooklyn Pizza

Neighborhood: Williamsburg & Bushwick
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For – A Night Out With Friends

Roberta’s is the hipster haven of Brooklyn pizza. Located in Bushwick, this pizzeria opened its doors in 2008 and has since become a destination for foodies and pizza lovers from all over.

Arguably the originator of the Brooklyn hipster restaurant oeuvre, Roberta’s has been serving up slices of joy that are now available frozen in your grocer’s freezer.

Roberta’s wood-fired pizzas are a must-try. Their pies are individual, light, and pillowy, with meats and salumi cured in-house. A crowd favorite is the Bee Sting, a delightful combination of tomato, mozzarella, soppressata, basil, chili, and honey.

Roberta’s prides itself on its veggies and entrées, too. Their Romaine salad, laced with garlic breadcrumbs, pecorino, and mint, is a refreshing treat that will delight your taste buds.

With shared picnic tables and white-washed brick, it’s the perfect spot for a casual night out with friends.

Just a heads up, Roberta’s doesn’t take reservations, and during primetime, waits can top an hour. But trust me; the wait is worth it.

8. Lucali – Your Slice of Romance in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Carroll Gardens
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect for: Date Night

If you’re looking for a romantic night out in Brooklyn, look no further than Lucali. This pizzeria is run by Mark Iacono, who has a knack for making scrumptious pizza pies that have earned him the nickname “The Pizza King of Brooklyn”

This Brooklyn gem has been serving up love at first bite since 2006, even earning a feature on Netflix’s Ugly Delicious.

Lucali is a BYOB pizzeria, so bring your favorite brew to pair with their mouthwatering pizza. Their menu is simple but sublime, offering large pizzas and calzones, all baked to perfection in a wood-and-gas-fired oven.

Their thin New York-style pies with crunchy crusts and a sweet but tangy tomato base testify to Lucali’s commitment to using farm-fresh, locally sourced ingredients. And the toppings? Each one adds an extra layer of deliciousness to your pizza.

Lucali is a hot spot, and they are only open for dinner.

So, get there for 3.30 pm for their 5 pm opening. They don’t take reservations, and it’s cash only, and each additional topping is an extra charge, but it’s worth every penny.

9. Pizza Wagon – The Family’s Favorite

Neighborhood: Bay Ridge
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: Quick Bites, Family Dinners

If you’re craving a slice of tradition, you can’t miss Pizza Wagon. This family-owned and operated pizzeria has been serving delicious pies since 1966, making it a beloved staple in the Brooklyn pizza scene.

At Pizza Wagon, pizza isn’t just food – it’s a family tradition passed down through generations. Every bite of their pizza is a taste of their rich history and dedication to the craft of pizza making.

Their classic and straightforward menu offers delicious, made-to-order pies, calzones, heroes, and more. The show’s star is its pizza slices, which come in plain or Sicilian style. 

Whether you like it thin and crispy or thick and fluffy, you will surely find something you love.

And whether you’re a fan of the classic Margherita or want to try something new and exciting, Pizza Wagon has got you covered. They also offer calzones, sandwiches, pasta, and salads.

For those looking for a quick bite or an affordable family dinner option, Pizza Wagon is the perfect place to get your pizza fix. Unfortunately, they don’t accept reservations.

Pro Tip: They don’t take credit cards – so be sure to bring cash.

10. Carmine’s Pizzeria – A Slice of Authentic Italian in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Williamsburg
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies and By The Slice
Perfect For: – Family Dinners, Casual Hangouts

Carmine’s Pizzeria, a beloved Brooklyn establishment, is renowned for its authentic Italian pizzas. Opened in 1978, this pizzeria has been serving the community with its delicious pizzas, a perfect blend of traditional and innovative flavors.

Their menu is extensive, offering both NY-style and specialty pizzas.

The Carmine’s Favorite Pie is a crowd favorite, made in a wood-fired oven with tomato sauce imported from Parma, Italy, and topped with grande mozzarella and grana Padano cheese.

The Five Cheese Grandma Pizza, a square pizza topped with various kinds of cheese, including mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, Buffalo mozzarella, Romano cheese, and Parmigiana Reggiano flakes, is another must-try.

For those who prefer a bit of creativity in their pizza, the Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza and the Philly Steak Pizza are excellent choices. They also offer a variety of Sicilian pizzas, including the traditional Sicilian Pie and the unique Baby Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza.

Carmine’s Pizzeria also offers a gluten-free seasoned cauliflower crust pizza for those with dietary restrictions. In addition to pizzas, they serve a variety of appetizers, salads, calzones, and pasta dishes.

The pizzeria offers whole pies and, by the slice, catering to all pizza cravings. The service is friendly, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting, making Carmine’s Pizzeria a perfect spot for a casual hangout or a family dinner.

11. Saraghina – A Cinematic Slice of Neapolitan Delight

Neighborhood: Bed-Stuy
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: Birthdays and Date Nights

If you’re looking for a pizza experience that’s as charming as it is delicious, then Saraghina is a must. Perfect for birthdays and date nights, this reservation-free spot is as welcoming as it is delightful.

Named for a character in the film 8 1/2, Saraghina serves up Neapolitan-style pizzas that are as memorable as the movie itself. They offer classic pizzas, including Margherita and rotating specialty pizzas to go with each season.

The Coppa & Carciofi is a crowd favorite, a delightful combination of mozzarella, hot coppa, roasted spicy artichokes, and basil.

Saraghina also boasts an impressive wine list, making it the perfect spot for a romantic date night or a celebratory dinner.

The ambiance at Saraghina is as delightful as their food. The inside feels like a very nice antique store, adding charm to your dining experience. And let’s not forget about their wood-burning oven, which adds a delightful smoky flavor to their pizzas.

12. Dellarocco’s – A Symphony of Flavors in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Brooklyn Heights
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: – A Night Out With Friends

Dellarocco’s is an Italian restaurant with a twist. This pizzeria opened in 2011 and specializes in Neapolitan-style pies and handmade pasta unique to the area.

With a clean and open dining area, this pizzeria offers a welcoming ambiance that’s perfect for a cozy dinner or a fun night out with friends.

The interior design of Dellarocco’s is simple yet beautiful, with a full wine bar and bright, airy windows that add a touch of elegance to your dining experience. But the real star of the show is their brick oven pizzas. Each pizza is a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.

Dellarocco’s offers a wide variety of red and white pizzas, so whether you’re a fan of the classic tomato base or prefer a creamy white pizza, they’ve got you covered. And for my gluten-free pizza lovers out there, don’t fret! Dellarocco’s offers a gluten-free crust option.

One of the crowd favorites is the Zucchini Pizza. It’s a delightful white pizza made with zucchini cream, smoked prosciutto, and mozzarella. It’s a unique combination that’s as tasty as it is innovative.

But Dellarocco’s isn’t just for the omnivores. They also offer a few vegan and vegetarian options for pies, making it a great spot for everyone. 

The rates are reasonable, and the service is friendly, adding to the delightful dining experience.

13. Totonno’s – Savor a Slice of History in Every Bite

Neighborhood: Coney Island
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: – A Night Out With Friends or a family gathering

In the heart of Coney Island, a family-owned pizzeria has been serving up slices of history since 1924. Welcome to Totonno’s, where pizza-making is a tradition passed down through generations.

This pizzeria is not just a restaurant; it’s a testament to the enduring legacy of the Pero family, who have been at the helm since its inception.

Totonno’s is the brainchild of Antonio “Totonno” Pero, an immigrant from Naples who started his pizza-making journey at Lombardi’s grocery store in Manhattan.

Today, his grandchildren continue to run the pizzeria, making Totonno’s the oldest, continually run, family-owned pizzeria in America.

Their philosophy is simple: as long as there’s dough, they will bake you the best pizza with the finest ingredients.

And they’re not just making claims; they’ve got the accolades to back it up. In 2009, Totonno was awarded the prestigious James Beard Award in the category of America’s Classics.

The pizzeria is known for its thin-crust pizzas, baked to perfection in its traditional brick oven. 

Their menu might not be extensive, but what they lack in variety, they make up for in quality. Each pizza is a labor of love, crafted with the finest ingredients and a lot of passion.

One of the standout features of Totonno is its ambiance. The pizzeria exudes a nostalgic charm that transports you back to the 1920s. It’s the perfect spot for a casual dinner or a date night.

However, before you plan your visit, check if they’re open. Their operating hours have been sporadic since reopening after the pandemic. But trust me, a slice of Totonno’s pizza is worth the wait!

So, if you’re ready to taste a slice of history, head over to Totonno’s. Because here, you’re not just eating a pizza; you’re experiencing a tradition that’s been alive for almost a century.

14. F&F Pizzeria – From Garage to Pizza Glory

Neighborhood: Carroll Gardens
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For:  Family Gatherings

Are you looking for a pizza place with a story as good as its slices? Then F&F Pizzeria is your next stop. This spot started off as a humble garage and has since been transformed into a full-fledged bar and pizzeria.

Talk about a glow-up!

Named after Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo, F&F Pizzeria keeps things simple with a menu offering only pies. But don’t let the simplicity fool you

Their toppings go beyond the average, offering delights like Mushroom, Sweet Fennel Sausage & Broccoli Rabe. And the fresh mozzarella cheese? It’s the stuff of pizza dreams.

F&F Pizzeria is not just about great pizza; it’s about a great experience.

There’s no pre-ordering here; it’s first come-first served. So, you get to enjoy the anticipation of waiting for your pizza masterpiece to be ready.

And let’s talk about their dough. They ferment it for about two or three days, giving it a depth of flavor that’s hard to beat. They import their tomatoes from California and bake their pizzas in a Swedish electric oven. Now, that’s what I call international pizza diplomacy.

F&F Pizzeria also offers Vegan options, so all my plant-based pizza lovers can join in on the fun. And if you’re a fan of al fresco dining, their outdoor seating area is the perfect spot to enjoy a slice under the Brooklyn sky.

15. L&B Spumoni Gardens – A Slice of Brooklyn’s History

Neighborhood: Dumbo, Bensonhurst
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies and Slices
Perfect For: Large Groups and Family Gatherings

Ready for a pizza place that’s as much a part of Brooklyn’s history as the Brooklyn Bridge itself? Then buckle up and head over to L&B Spumoni Gardens. This spot has been serving up slices of joy since 1938. That’s over 80 years of pizza perfection.

L&B Spumoni Gardens offers table service and a lengthy menu that’s sure to have something for everyone. But the star of the show is undoubtedly their Sicilian pizza. Some even say it’s the best Sicilian pizza in Brooklyn. And let me tell you, that’s no small feat.

Their $4 grandma pizza slice at the window to go is a crowd favorite. But if you’re a fan of the square slice, you’re in for a treat. Their famous square slice is a must-try for any pizza lover.

And the best part? They offer both slices and pies. So, whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite or a pizza feast, they’ve got you covered.

L&B Spumoni Gardens uses a deck oven to bake their pizzas to crispy, cheesy perfection. And if you’re a fan of al fresco dining, their always-bustling outdoor seating area is the perfect spot to enjoy a slice under the Brooklyn sky.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at pizza. You’ve got to try their famous Spumoni, an Italian ice cream dessert that’s the perfect sweet ending to your pizza adventure.

And guess what? They’re expanding! Their website says a DUMBO location will be coming soon. So, get ready for more pizza goodness in the heart of Brooklyn.

16. Pauli Gee’s – A Slice of the 70s with a Modern Twist

Neighborhood: Greenpoint
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: Casual Weeknight dinner

If you’re in the mood for a casual weeknight dinner and some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, then Pauli Gee’s is your next pizza destination. With its 1970s vibe, this pizzeria serves up foldable, famous New York-style slices that are as delicious as they are nostalgic.

Their wood-fired pizza is a must-try. The “Hellboy” slice—with hot honey and spicy pepperoni—is a crowd favorite. And if you’re a fan of white pizza, their garlicky white slice (called “The Mootz”) with cheese and olive oil is a delight.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at traditional pizzas. Pauli Gee’s also offers a full vegan pizza menu and even a secret pizza menu for those looking for a pizza adventure.

And the best part? The cozy and welcoming atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a casual dinner.

17. Emily – A Love Story Baked into Every Slice

Neighborhood: Clinton Hill
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: Date Night and Celebrations

If you believe in love stories and pizza, then Emily is the place for you. This pizzeria is the brainchild of Matt and Emily, two people who turned their love for pies into a famous pizzeria. Talk about relationship goals.

Emily’s menu changes with the seasons, reflecting their commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. And their pizzas? They’re baked perfectly in a wood-fired oven, giving them a smoky, irresistible flavor.

Their favorite pizzas include the Colony— a delightful mix of sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, pickled chili, and honey, and the Emily— a heavenly combination of mozzarella, pistachio, truffle sottocenere, and honey-stuffed pizza.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at pizza. They’re also known for their Emmy Burger, a must-try for any burger lover. Just keep in mind it’s so perfect it cannot be modified.

The warm, welcoming ambiance is the perfect backdrop for a pizza feast. And for all my gluten-free pizza lovers out there, don’t worry; they’ve got options for you too.

18. Emmy Squared – Detroit-Style Pizza Delight in the Heart of Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Williamsburg
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For: Late-Night Hangouts

Ready for a late-night slice of pizza perfection? Then Emmy Squared is your next stop. This pizzeria serves up Detroit-style pies that are as cheesy and delicious as they are filling.

This franchise, founded in New York by the same folks behind Emily, has been serving up slices of joy since 2016 from its flagship location in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

Emmy Squared is always bustling with pizza enthusiasts, so make a reservation. Their Detroit-style pizza, baked in a deck oven, is a must-try, with a crunchy, “frico” crust and rich tomato sauce that will have you coming back for more.

And if you’re a fan of spice, their famous pizza Colony2 – pepperoni, pickled jalapeno, and hot honey pizza is a crowd favorite. But the goodness doesn’t stop at pizza. Their Cheesy Garlic sticks are a must-try (with fresh garlic).

And the best part? You can download their app and receive rewards for your Emmy Squared pickup and delivery orders. Now, that’s what we call a win-win.

But wait, there’s more; Emmy Squared offers Emmy’s pizza summer hour, where you can enjoy 20% off pizza and drinks.

And if you’re a burger lover, you’re in for a treat. Emmy’s Le Big Matt Burger has been recognized as one of ‘The Best New Burgers in NYC’ (Gothamist) and one of the ’20 Best Burgers in NYC” (Infatuation).

19. Giuseppina’s – A Slice of Family Tradition in Park Slope

Neighborhood: South Slope
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: – A Delicious Family Meal

Giuseppina’s is a must-visit if you’re on a pizza pilgrimage in Brooklyn. This gem, opened in 2011, is the brainchild of Chris Iacono, who honed his pizza-making skills at his brother Mark’s pizzeria, Lucali, before opening this Park Slope spot.

Giuseppina’s is all about top-tier ingredients and a secret sauce recipe passed down from Grandma Giuseppina herself. This secret sauce is the heart of their pizzas, lovingly spread between the thin crust and the mouthwatering toppings.

The 40-seat eatery offers an identical menu of classic calzones and thin-crust pizzas. But don’t let the simplicity fool you. Each dish is a symphony of flavors that will have your taste buds dancing.

One of the coolest things about Giuseppina’s is that guests can watch flour-dusted chefs punch and pull mounds of dough in front of a wood-fired oven. It’s like a live pizza-making show that adds to the overall dining experience.

They offer traditional options like plain or white, unique specialty, and tasty calzones. But remember, it’s cash only, so come prepared.

So, if you’re ready for an Alfredo pizza experience that’s as unique as it is delicious, make your way to Giuseppina’s.

20. Ignazio’s – A Slice of Romance Under the Brooklyn Bridge

Neighborhood: Brooklyn Heights
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: Date Night and Celebrations

If you’re looking for a romantic pizza night out, then Ignazio’s is the place for you. This pizzeria, located in Brooklyn Heights and just minutes away from the Brooklyn Bridge, serves up Neapolitan-style pies that are as delicious as they are Instagram-worthy.

Ignazio’s, rated an impressive 8.7/10 by pizza connoisseur Dave Portnoy, is a testament to the art of pizza making.

Their pizzas are a symphony of flavors, with a crust that’s the perfect balance of chewy and crispy and a rich and tangy sauce. And let’s not forget the toppings. From classic favorites to unique creations, there’s a pizza for every palate.

One of the stars of the show is their “create your own” option, where you can choose from a long list of delicious toppings to create your own pizza masterpiece. But if you’re not in the mood to play chef, their menu has mouthwatering options.

Their pizzas are baked in a wood-fired oven, giving them a distinct flavor that’s hard to resist. And with their commitment to using top-tier ingredients, you can be sure that every bite is as delicious as the last.

But Ignazio’s isn’t just about pizza. They also offer a variety of other dishes, from salads to sandwiches, all prepared with the same attention to detail and quality ingredients.

Just a heads up, Ignazio’s is a popular spot, so it’s always a good idea to make a reservation. So, if you’re ready for a pizza experience that’s as romantic as it is delicious, then make your way to Ignazio’s.

21. Motorino – Neapolitan Delights in the Heart of Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Williamsburg
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pie Only
Perfect For:  Gourmet Pizza Lovers

If you’re in the mood for a pizza experience that’s as authentic as it is delicious, then Motorino is your next stop. With locations in Brooklyn and on the Upper West Side, you’re never too far from a slice of their pizza heaven.

Motorino serves up Neapolitan pies as plump and crisp as they come. The wood-fired crusts have a hint of char that adds a delightful smoky flavor to each bite.

 And the toppings? Oh, the toppings! They’re well-sourced and add an extra layer of deliciousness to your pizza.

One of the crowd favorites is the Brussels sprout pizza. Yes, you heard that right, Brussels sprout pizza. It’s a unique combination that’s supremely delicious. Trust me, your taste buds are in for a treat.

Motorino is perfect for casual dinners or a well-priced pre-fixe. The ambiance is as delightful as their food, making it a great spot for a cozy dinner or a fun night out with friends.

22. Barboncino – Neapolitan Pizzeria & Bar in the Heart of Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Crown Heights
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: – Pizza Night and Cocktails

Barboncino, a gem in the heart of Crown Heights, Brooklyn, is where pizza meets perfection. Since its inception in 2011, this Neapolitan pizzeria and bar has been redefining the pizza scene with its unique blend of traditional and innovative offerings.

The atmosphere at Barboncino is as enticing as its menu.

With a daily happy hour from 3-6 pm, it’s the perfect spot to relax, unwind, and indulge in some of the best pizzas in town. And if you’re in the mood for a drink, their creative cocktails will surely hit the spot.

Their pizza menu is a delightful mix of red and white pizzas, catering to various taste buds. The Eggplant & Zucchini pizza is a known favorite, a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.

So, if you’re looking for a pizza experience that’s as unique as it is delicious, then make your way to Barboncino. It’s not just a pizzeria; it’s a celebration of pizza at its finest.

23. L’Industrie – A Slice of Authentic Italy in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Williamsburg
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies and Slices
Perfect For: A Relaxed Pizza Hangout

If you’re looking for a laidback hangout spot with delicious pizza, then L’Industrie won’t disappoint. This cozy Italian joint is located in the heart of Brooklyn’s Williamsburg neighborhood and serves up pies that are as traditional as they come.

This popular slice shop opened in 2017 and is the new kid on the block, but it’s already making a big splash in the pizza scene.

L’Industrie uses a long fermentation process for their crust, resulting in a deliciously crunchy bite every time. The thin-crust pizza is topped with minimal tomato sauce, fresh basil, and grated parmesan on every slice. It’s like a little trip to Italy with every bite.

But what sets L’Industrie apart is their commitment to quality. They use fresh ingredients directly imported from Italy. So, you’re not just getting a pizza; you’re getting a slice of authentic Italian craftsmanship.

One of the crowd favorites is the burrata slice. It’s a non-negotiable if you’re a fan of creamy, dreamy burrata. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

While L’Industrie is a popular slice shop, you can also get whole pies. So, whether you’re in the mood for a quick slice or a full-on pizza feast, L’Industrie has got you covered.

24. Table 87 – Brooklyn’s Coal Oven Pizza Paradise

Neighborhood: Brooklyn Heights, Gowanus, Sunset Park
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies and Slices
Perfect For: Groups and Celebrations

Table 87 is Brooklyn’s one-stop shop for coal oven-fired pizza goodness. They offer whole pies and slices, so you can get your pizza fix any time. And if you’re in the mood for a flavor adventure, their specialty pizzas are sure to please.

With three locations in different neighborhoods of Brooklyn and pop-up locations at Barclays Center and Coney Island, you’re never too far from a slice of their pizza heaven with Table 87.

Since opening its doors in 2012, Table 87 has served up slices of joy. They offer both square and regular-style pies, so whether you’re a classic slice or hip square fan, they’ve got you covered.

In the summer, they offer an outdoor cinema experience with a projector on the Smith & 9th Street subway. Now, that’s what I call dinner and a show.

The most recommended pizza is the Coal Oven Margherita Pizza, which includes a crispy crust that’s slightly charred, a tangy San Marzano tomato sauce, house-made mozzarella, fresh basil, and a drizzle of olive oil.

But the deliciousness doesn’t stop there. They also offer a selection of sandwiches, paninis, salads, and more. So whether you’re looking for a slice or something else, Table 87 will satisfy your cravings.

25. Nonno’s Pizza – A Taste of Italy in Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Bay Ridge
Pie vs. Slices: Whole Pies Only
Perfect For: Casual Dinners, Quick Bites

Nonno’s Pizza, a popular spot in Brooklyn, has been serving up delicious Italian cuisine since its opening. With a wide variety of offerings, from traditional pizzas to calzones, sandwiches, and salads, Nonno’s has something for everyone.

Baked in a traditional brick oven, their pizzas are known for their thin, crispy crust and the right balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings.

Their Alla Vodka Pizza and White Pizza, a sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, are crowd favorites.

For those who prefer to venture beyond pizza, Nonno’s also offers a variety of other Italian dishes. Their menu includes a range of pasta dishes, baked dishes, and dinner entrees, all prepared with the same attention to quality and flavor.

Nonno’s is also known for its accommodating service and commitment to using high-quality ingredients, many of which are imported directly from Italy. This commitment is evident in their specialty slices, carefully assembled with handmade components.

The pizzeria is a cash-only establishment, so be sure to have some on hand when you visit. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Nonno’s Pizza is a must-visit for a taste of authentic Italian pizza in Brooklyn.

FINAL NOTE: BEST PIZZA IN BROOKLYN

I hope you found this guide to the best pizza in Brooklyn super helpful. While you can find a pizza parlor on just about any corner in Brooklyn, I hope you find the time to look for the spots that both Brooklynites and travelers alike find to be top-notch pizza in the borough.

Had your fill of some of the best pizza in Brooklyn? Why not check out some of my other posts on my site about Brooklyn?

Ready for a vacation? Part of my blog also focuses on world travels and provides helpful tips for that perfect journey abroad. Happy travels!

FAQ: BEST PIZZA IN BROOKLYN

Why is Brooklyn famous for pizza?

Brooklyn’s pizza fame is due to its historic pizzerias and the borough’s influence on pizza culture.

What is a Brooklyn-style pizza?

Brooklyn-style pizza is characterized by a thin and foldable crust, often with a slightly crispy bottom, and a focus on quality toppings. However, the best pizza in Brooklyn presents in a variety of ways!

What goes on a Brooklyn pizza?

If you’re having the best pizza in Brooklyn, chances are you will be trying a pizza that is super traditional or extremely original in it’s ingredient combination. Try it all and have fun!

25 Spots for the Best Pizza in Brooklyn, New York (2023)

Author Avatar

RELATED BLOGS

Check out related blogs below!

Street in Park Slope lined with brownstones, part of the best things to do in Park Slope

Best Things To Do in Park Slope, Brooklyn (2024)

Are you looking for the best things to do in Park Slope, Brooklyn? You’ve come to the right place. Imagine walking through this vibrant neighborhood, uncovering its hidden gems and well-loved spots. This guide is your key to the best experiences Park Slope offers, where history and modern vibes blend seamlessly. You’ll find a mix […]

Front of home in Dyker Heights Christmas Lights

Festive Dyker Heights Christmas Lights Guide (2024)

You’re about to discover the magic of Dyker Heights during the festive Christmas season. Imagine walking down streets illuminated by millions of twinkling lights, each corner revealing a new, dazzling holiday spectacle. This guide is your key to exploring the best Dyker Heights Christmas Lights. Think of this as your personal tour through a neighborhood […]

Assorted bagels as part of the best bagels in Brooklyn post

20 Spots For The Best Bagels In Brooklyn

Welcome to Brooklyn, New York’s famous borough known for its amazing bagels. Bagels here are more than just breakfast; they’re a special part of the city’s flavor.  In this guide, I’ll take you through 20 of the best spots for bagels in Brooklyn. You’ll find everything from the classic New York-style bagels to new, exciting […]